Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Spence's avatar

Roland Kirk has an album called "I talk with spirits"

Expand full comment
Spence's avatar

This larger lyrical chunk provides significant context and strongly reinforces the interpretation of Horatio from Shakespeare's Hamlet, specifically playing on both his observational role and potentially a critical take on a limited perspective.

Let's break down why this fits so well:

* "What becomes of the broken-hearted? The broken spirits, the broke and starving / Smoke and mirrors in a Sulfur garden": This immediately establishes a bleak, critical, and almost apocalyptic tone. "Sulfur garden" evokes hellish imagery, suggesting a corrupt and suffering world.

* "We got safety nets with gaping holes / Don't mistake your narrow lens for the greater whole / Horatio": As previously discussed, this is a direct address to someone who is not seeing the full picture of societal failings. The speaker is urging them to broaden their understanding beyond a limited viewpoint.

* "While some move and shake spearheading our collective fate, others pay the toll / On roads' paved with skulls, post violent force": This is where the Hamlet connection becomes even stronger.

* "spearheading": This word choice, combined with "Shakespeare," is a very strong and deliberate pun on "Shakespeare." It directly brings the Bard into the lyrical landscape.

* "collective fate, others pay the toll / On roads' paved with skulls, post violent force": This speaks to the grand, tragic narratives of power, conflict, and sacrifice that are central to Hamlet and other Shakespearean tragedies. Empires being built on violence and the suffering of the many align perfectly with the themes of many of his plays.

* "Empire's aren't built with scraps from the Dollar Store / Tangled woven webs, carrots dangled overhead / The whole thing'll fall apart if you pull a thread": These lines describe complex systems of power, manipulation, and the fragility of grand structures. This mirrors the intricate political machinations and deceptions within the Danish court in Hamlet. The "tangled woven webs" and the idea of "pulling a thread" to unravel everything evoke a sense of deep-seated corruption and interconnectedness.

* "Each vying for a slice of the pie graph / Watching time pass where the blind lead the blind at": This paints a picture of societal decay, self-interest, and a lack of true leadership or insight. The "blind lead the blind" perfectly encapsulates the tragic downfall when those in power are misguided or lack true vision.

How it all ties back to Hamlet's Horatio:

* The Direct Address and Criticism of "Narrow Lens": The speaker is calling out someone named or being likened to Horatio. In this context, it's not the "ideal observer" Horatio, but rather a "Horatio" who is failing to see the brutal realities ("gaping holes," "roads paved with skulls," "smoke and mirrors"). The speaker is urging them to open their eyes to the "greater whole" of suffering, manipulation, and systemic failure.

* The "Shakespeare" Pun: The explicit "spearheading our collective fate" is almost certainly a direct nod to Shakespeare himself, which then grounds the "Horatio" reference firmly in the world of Hamlet.

* Themes of Tragedy, Power, and Deception: The overarching themes of brokenness, violence, empire-building on suffering, manipulation, and systemic fragility are hallmarks of Shakespearean tragedy, and Hamlet specifically. Horatio, as the loyal but often disbelieving or initially naive observer, is the perfect figure to address when discussing those who might be overlooking the harsh realities.

* The Call to Witness and Act: Just as Hamlet charges Horatio with telling his story to the world, the speaker here seems to be urging the "Horacio" in question to truly see and understand the dire state of affairs, perhaps implying a responsibility to act or at least acknowledge the truth.

Therefore, "Horatio" in these lyrics is almost certainly a reference to Horatio from Shakespeare's Hamlet. The song uses him as an archetype for someone who might be intelligent and observational but is, at least in the speaker's eyes, either initially blind to the full scope of the world's problems or is being urged to transcend a limited understanding to truly grasp the profound brokenness and manipulation at play. The "spearheading" pun seals the deal for this interpretation.

Expand full comment

No posts